@r_anderson96 I have been in the exact same situation.
Ended up with Oz Racing Ultraleggera 18x8 wheels, in bronze

. They also come in other colors and are very light and nice looking too

. Will be put on the car in April.
View attachment 11579
For tires I have been torn between Michelin Pilot Sport 4 and 4S. Short summary: Both are great tires. If you want a little bias on comfort go for the 4, if you plan on going to the track regularly go for 4S.
For me it was the 4, because I want more comfort (but still sport tires).
As for dimenions, go for the 235/40/18. If you go for a 225/4018 the sidewall is shorter (4 mm).